Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, located in the gorgeous Florida Keys, has been a source of rustic appeal since its inception in 1976 by Jeff Macfarland. This modest café, named after Jeff’s mother, immediately gained popularity among locals. The addition of Angie and her sister Paula in 1987 cemented its place as a Key Largo institution. Stephanie Figueroa, a long-time local, took up the job of safeguarding its heritage in April 2023, ensuring that its warm and community-focused culture lives on. The restaurant’s motto, “Eat Well, Laugh Often, Live Long,” aptly captures its eating philosophy, emphasizing joy, wonderful food, and lasting memories. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, known for its homestyle cooking, fresh seafood, steaks, and global-inspired meals, is a favorite among both locals and visitors, providing a one-of-a-kind and soothing eating experience in the heart of the Florida Keys.
Outside
Restaurant’s pastel pink walls and aqua window trims give the entrance a warm, classic Florida appeal. Above, against a backdrop of sky and vegetation, the restaurant’s motto, “Eat Well, Laugh Often, Live Long,” is proudly displayed on the corrugated metal roof, inviting patrons to embrace the easygoing, joyful way of life that the Keys are renowned for. White rocking chairs adorn the façade, giving the impression of a location where people may unwind and enjoy life’s small joys.
Inside Big Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen has a colorful and warm ambiance that is uniquely Florida Keys. The dining area feels open and light, thanks to the blue sky-painted ceiling. The decor is quirky and full of local character, with unusual lampshades made from license plates, historical images framed on the walls, and an art piece filled with bright maritime relics. The bar area is inviting, encouraging customers to unwind while they eat, and the overall atmosphere is one in which every corner tells a story, reflecting the Keys’ rich history and community spirit.
Food
Fish Tacos @ Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen Key Largo, FL: The fish tacos we tasted were a flavorful pleasure, with well seasoned blackened local Mahi-mahi. The fish was tucked inside soft flour tortillas and served with fresh pico de gallo, melty Colby Jack cheese, crisp cabbage, and creamy guacamole. Each component was mixed to create a delectable combination of textures and flavors, evoking the fresh essence of coastal cuisine.
Littleneck Clams @ Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen Key Largo, FL: Clams were delicious, served in a garlic butter sauce with a hint of white wine and scattered fresh herbs. The clams were soft and tasty, and the aromatic sauce balanced them out well. Along with the entrée, the garlic bread was crunchy and delicious, making it a pleasure to dip into the broth and absorb all of the dish’s flavor. It was a great meal that demonstrated their dedication to fresh, homestyle seafood.
Kids Mozzarella Sticks @ Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen Key Largo, FL: With a side of marinara sauce, the Kids Mozzarella Sticks serve as a traditional comfort dish. They fit the description of a normal appetizer; they have a golden-brown outside and an interior of melted cheese. Even if they have a well-known flavor, they might not be distinguished as a distinctive dish in comparison to other interesting options.
Kids Mini Corn Dogs @ Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen Key Largo, FL: If you’re planning to try the Kids Mini Corn Dogs at Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen next time, it might be worth considering different options on the menu to enhance your dining experience. The mini corn dogs, accompanied by crinkle-cut chips, are a classic snack but might fall short of expectations for those seeking a more unique or standout dish.
Free Mini Kid’s Cone @ Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen Key Largo, FL: The complimentary mini ice cream cone, offered upon request with a meal purchase, was a delightful treat. It was a tasty and pleasant end to the meal, much appreciated for its sweet simplicity.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen Menu
Menu date 03/28/2024
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen Online Menu
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen exemplified Key Largo’s laid-back character, from the welcoming slogan above to the diverse and homey decor. While several classic kid-friendly items were subpar, the complimentary tiny ice cream cone gave a pleasant finish. It serves as a reminder that little actions, such as providing free ice cream, can have a lasting impact. Overall, the atmosphere outperformed the basic menu items, capturing the flavor of the Florida Keys eating scene.
